{ "texte_version": { "JORFTEXT000000748893": { "SM": { "CONTENU": "LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL,SAISI PAR PLUS DE 60 SENATEURS,A DECLARE CONFORME A LA CONSTITUTION LA LOI RELATIVE AUX PLANS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE.
1) SUR LE GRIEF DE LA REMISE EN CAUSE DU DROIT A PENSION,LE CONSEIL CONSIDERE QUE LA LOI N'A PAS POUR OBJET DE METTRE EN CAUSE LE PRINCIPE OU L'ORGANISATION DE L'ASSURANCE VIEILLESSE.ELLE SE BORNE A INSTITUER UN SYSTEME FACULTATIF D'EPARGNE EN VUE DE LA RETRAITE.
2) TOUT EN REJETANT LES GRIEFS RELATIFS A LA MECONNAISSANCE DE L'ETENDUE DE LA COMPETENCE DU LEGISLATEUR,LE CONSEIL AFFIRME QU'AUCUNE REGLE CONSTITUTIONNELLE NE GARANTIT LE PRINCIPE DIT DE L'EQUITE ENTRE LES GENERATIONS ET RAPPELLE QU'IL PEUT SE PRONONCER SUR LA CONSTITUTIONNALITE DES LOIS PROMULGUEES A L'OCCASION DE L'EXAMEN DE DISPOSITIONS LEGISLATIVES QUI LES MODIFIENT,LES COMPLETENT,OU AFFECTENT SON DOMAINE.
3) LE CONSEIL REJETTE UN CERTAIN NOMBRE DE NOUVEAUX PRINCIPES CONSTITUTIONNELS QUE LES REQUERANTS SOUHAITAIENT VOIR APPLIQUER (PRINCIPE DE FAVEUR,PRINCIPE DE LIBERTE CONTRACTUELLE ET PRINCIPE DE L'AUTONOMIE DE LA VOLONTE).
4) LE CONSEIL REJETTE EGALEMENT LES DIFFERENTS GRIEFS RELATIFS A LA VIOLATION DU PRINCIPE D'EGALITE EN RAPPELANT SA JURISPRUDENCE CONSTANTE SUR LA POSSIBILITE DE REGLER DIFFEREMMENT DES SITUATIONS DIFFERENTES ET SUR LA POSSIBILITE DE DEROGER A CE PRINCIPE POUR DES MOTIFS D'INTERET GENERAL POURVU QUE LA DIFFERENCE DE TRAITEMENT SOIT EN RAPPORT DIRECT AVEC L'OBJET DE LA LOI QUI L'ETABLIT." }, "META": { "META_SPEC": { "META_TEXTE_VERSION": { "LIENS": { "LIEN": [ { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "#text": "Loi n°97-277 du 25 mars 1997", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "@nortexte": "ECOX9601788L", "@numtexte": "97-277", "@typelien": "MODIFIE", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1997-03-25" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "#text": "Saisine", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "@nortexte": "CSCL9701969X", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "SAISINE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000019943654", "#text": "Observations du - art., v. init.", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000019943653", "@nortexte": "CSCL0829020X", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "OBSERVATION", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000020352447", "#text": "Mémoire du - art., v. init.", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000020352446", "@nortexte": "CSCL0904905X", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "MEMOIRE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000020352452", "#text": "Mémoire du - art., v. init.", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000020352451", "@nortexte": "CSCL0904903X", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "MEMOIRE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000020352419", "#text": "Observations du - art., v. init.", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000020352418", "@nortexte": "CSCL0904205X", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "OBSERVATION", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" } ] }, "TITRE": "Décision n°97-388 du 20 mars 1997", "MCS_TXT": { "MC": [ "CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL", "PLAN D'EPARGNE RETRAITE", "CONFORMITE A LA CONSTITUTION", "CONSTITUTIONNALITE", "RETRAITE", "FONDS", "FONDS DE PENSION", "PRINCIPE D'EGALITE", "COMPETENCE", "LEGISLATEUR", "PREAMBULE", "DECLARATION DES DROITS DE L'HOMME", "SENAT", "SENATEUR" ] }, "AUTORITE": "CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL", "TITREFULL": "CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL Décision no 97-388 DC du 20 mars 1997" }, "META_TEXTE_CHRONICLE": { "CID": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "NOR": "CSCL9701972S", "NUM": "97-388", "DATE_PUBLI": "1997-03-26", "DATE_TEXTE": "1997-03-20", "ORIGINE_PUBLI": "JORF n°72 du 26 mars 1997", "PAGE_DEB_PUBLI": 4661, "PAGE_FIN_PUBLI": 19970326 } }, "META_COMMUN": { "ID": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "URL": "texte/version/JORF/TEXT/00/00/00/74/88/JORFTEXT000000748893.xml", "NATURE": "DECISION", "ORIGINE": "JORF", "ANCIEN_ID": "2DC997388" } }, "SIGNATAIRES": { "CONTENU": "

Le président,

Roland Dumas

" } }, "JORFTEXT000000198906": { "SM": { "CONTENU": "CHAP. I: LES PLANS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE (ART. 1 A 7).
SALARIES CONCERNES ET MODALITES D'ADHESION.
CHAP. II: LES FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE (ART. 8 A 13): CONDITIONS DANS LESQUELLES LES FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE POURRONT ETRE CONSTITUES.CEUX-CI SONT IMPERATIVEMENT CONSTITUES SOUS L'UNE DES FORMES SUIVANTES: SOCIETE ANONYME D'ASSURANCE,SOCIETE D'ASSURANCE MUTUELLE,INSTITUTION DE PREVOYANCE,REGIE PAR LE TITRE III DU LIVRE IX DU CODE DE LA SECURITE SOCIALE,ORGANISME MUTUALISTE.
MODALITES D'AGREMENT DES FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE.
CHAP. III: LES COMITES DE SURVEILLANCE (ART. 14 A 16): COMPOSITION ET COMPETENCE.
CHAP. IV: LE CONTROLE DES FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE (ART. 17 A 20): MODALITES DE CONTROLE DE L'ETAT.MODALITES DE FONCTIONNEMENT DE LA COMMISSION DE CONTROLE DES ASSURANCES ET DE LA COMMISSION DE CONTROLE MENTIONNEE A L'ART. L951-1 DU CODE DE LA SECURITE SOCIALE.
LE CONTROLE DE L'ETAT SUR LES FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE S'EXERCE CONFORMEMENT AUX DISPOSITIONS DES ART. L310-8,L310-9,L310-12-1 (AL. 8,11) ET L310-13 A L310-28 DU CODE DES ASSURANCES.
CHAP. V: INFORMATION DES ADHERENTS (ART. 21 A 25).
DEFINIT LES OBLIGATIONS D'INFORMATION DES ADHERENTS A LA CHARGE,D'UNE PART,DES SOUSCRIPTEURS DE PLANS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE ET D'AUTRE PART DES FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE.
CHAP. VI: REGLES JURISPRUDENTIELLES APPLICABLES AUX FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE (ART. 23 A 25).
CHAP. VII (ART. 26 A 31): DISPOSITIONS FINANCIERES.
MODIFIE LES ART. 83 (1EREMENT-TER),158 (B-BIS DU 5 ET INSERE UN B-TER),206 (COMPLETE PAR UN 11),209-BIS (LE 3),219-QUATER DU CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS.
CHAP. VIII: DISPOSITIONS DIVERSES (ART. 32).
MODIFIE L'ART. 32-1 (AL. 1) DE LA LOI 90568 DU 02-07-1990 RELATIVE A L'ORGANISATION DU SERVICE PUBLIC DE LA POSTE ET DES TELECOMMUNICATIONS.ETEND AU PERSONNEL RETRAITE,DEPUIS MOINS DE 5 ANS,DE FRANCE TELECOM ET POUVANT SE PREVALOIR D'UNE ANCIENNETE SUPERIEURE A 5 ANS DANS UN EMPLOI D'UN SERVICE RELEVANT DE LA DIRECTION GENERALE DES TELECOMMUNICATIONS,LE BENEFICE DES DISPOSITIONS RELATIVES A L'INTERESSEMENT ET A LA PARTICIPATION DES SALARIES AUX RESULTATS DE L'ENTREPRISE ET A L'ACTIONNARIAT DES SALARIES." }, "TP": { "CONTENU": "(1) Loi no 97-277.
- Travaux préparatoires :
Assemblée nationale :
Proposition de loi nos 741 et 1039 ;
Rapport de M. Jean-Pierre Thomas, au nom de la commission des finances, no 1286 ;
Discussion les 30 mai, 21 et 22 novembre 1996 et adoption le 22 novembre 1996.
Sénat :
Proposition de loi, adoptée par l'Assemblée nationale, no 100 (1996-1997) ; Rapport de M. Philippe Marini, au nom de la commission des finances, no 124 (1996-1997) ;
Discussion les 12 et 13 décembre 1996 et adoption le 13 décembre 1996.
Assemblée nationale :
Proposition de loi, modifiée par le Sénat, no 3237 ;
Rapport de M. Jean-Pierre Thomas, au nom de la commission des finances, no 3286 ;
Discussion les 14 et 15 janvier 1997 et adoption le 15 janvier 1997.
Sénat :
Proposition de loi, adoptée avec modifications par l'Assemblée nationale en deuxième lecture, no 179 (1996-1997) ;
Rapport de M. Philippe Marini, au nom de la commission des finances, no 190 (1996-1997) ;
Discussion et adoption le 30 janvier 1997.
Sénat :
Rapport de M. Philippe Marini, au nom de la commission mixte paritaire, no 206 (1996-1997) ;
Discussion et adoption le 20 février 1997.
Assemblée nationale :
Proposition de loi, modifiée par le Sénat en deuxième lecture, no 3326 ;
Rapport de M. Jean-Pierre Thomas, au nom de la commission mixte paritaire,
no 3331 ;
Discussion et adoption le 20 février 1997.
- Conseil constitutionnel :
Décision no 97-388 DC du 20 mars 1997 publiée au Journal officiel du 26 mars 1997.
" }, "ABRO": { "CONTENU": "Texte totalement abrogé" }, "META": { "META_SPEC": { "META_TEXTE_VERSION": { "LIENS": { "LIEN": [ { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000692245", "#text": "Loi n°66-537 du 24 juillet 1966", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000692245", "@numtexte": "66-537", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1966-07-24" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000698676", "#text": "Ordonnance n°67-833 du 28 septembre 1967", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000698676", "@numtexte": "67-833", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "ORDONNANCE", "@datesignatexte": "1967-09-28" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000509065", "#text": "Loi n°88-1201 du 23 décembre 1988", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000509065", "@nortexte": "ECOX8800123L", "@numtexte": "88-1201", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1988-12-23" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000716493", "#text": "Loi n°90-568 du 2 juillet 1990", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000716493", "@nortexte": "PTTX9000053L", "@numtexte": "90-568", "@typelien": "MODIFIE", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1990-07-02" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000193847", "#text": "Loi n°96-597 du 2 juillet 1996", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000193847", "@nortexte": "ECOX9500164L", "@numtexte": "96-597", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1996-07-02" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000380034", "#text": "Loi n°96-1181 du 30 décembre 1996", "@sens": "source", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000380034", "@nortexte": "ECOX9600105L", "@numtexte": "96-1181", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1996-12-30" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "#text": "DECISION97-388", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "@nortexte": "CSCL9701972S", "@numtexte": "97-388", "@typelien": "MODIFIE", "@naturetexte": "DECISION", "@datesignatexte": "1997-03-20" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006758026", "@num": "Annexe", "#text": "Loi n°98-1194 du 23 décembre 1998 - art. Annexe (V)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000392993", "@nortexte": "MESX9800131L", "@numtexte": "98-1194", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "1998-12-23" }, { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000408905", "#text": "LOI2002-73", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000408905", "@nortexte": "MESX0000077L", "@numtexte": "2002-73", "@typelien": "ABROGE", "@naturetexte": "LOI", "@datesignatexte": "2002-01-17" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307976", "@num": "158", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 158 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307975", "@num": "158", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 158 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307977", "@num": "158", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 158 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307979", "@num": "158", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 158 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307980", "@num": "158", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 158 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307978", "@num": "158", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 158 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006308490", "@num": "206", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 206 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006308491", "@num": "206", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 206 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006308492", "@num": "206", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 206 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006303910", "@num": "235 ter Y", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 235 ter Y (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006303909", "@num": "235 ter Y", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 235 ter Y (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307115", "@num": "83", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 83 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307114", "@num": "83", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 83 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006307113", "@num": "83", "#text": "CODE GENERAL DES IMPOTS, CGI. - art. 83 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006069577", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006745896", "@num": "L951-3", "#text": "Code de la sécurité sociale. - art. L951-3 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006073189", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006745897", "@num": "L951-3", "#text": "Code de la sécurité sociale. - art. L951-3 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006073189", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006796438", "@num": "L310-12", "#text": "Code des assurances - art. L310-12 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006073984", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006796437", "@num": "L310-12", "#text": "Code des assurances - art. L310-12 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006073984", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006796439", "@num": "L310-12", "#text": "Code des assurances - art. L310-12 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006073984", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" }, { "@id": "LEGIARTI000006796440", "@num": "L310-12", "#text": "Code des assurances - art. L310-12 (M)", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "LEGITEXT000006073984", "@typelien": "CITATION", "@naturetexte": "CODE", "@datesignatexte": "2999-01-01" } ] }, "TITRE": "Loi n°97-277 du 25 mars 1997", "MCS_TXT": { "MC": [ "RETRAITE", "EPARGNE", "PLAN D'EPARGNE RETRAITE", "FONDS DE PENSION", "CAPITALISATION", "SALARIE", "ASSURANCE VIEILLESSE", "ADHESION", "ADHERENT", "FONDS D'EPARGNE RETRAITE", "CREATION", "AGREMENT", "CONTROLE DE L'ETAT", "ACTIONNAIRE", "INFORMATION", "COMITE DE SURVEILLANCE", "COMMISSION DE CONTROLE DES ASSURANCES", "SOUSCRIPTEUR", "FRANCE TELECOM", "PARTICIPATION", "INTERESSEMENT", "CGI", "CODE DE LA SECURITE SOCIALE", "PROPOSITION DE LOI", "LOI THOMAS" ] }, "TITREFULL": "LOI no 97-277 du 25 mars 1997 créant les plans d'épargne retraite (1)" }, "META_TEXTE_CHRONICLE": { "CID": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "NOR": "ECOX9601788L", "NUM": "97-277", "DATE_PUBLI": "1997-03-26", "DATE_TEXTE": "1997-03-25", "ORIGINE_PUBLI": "JORF n°72 du 26 mars 1997", "PAGE_DEB_PUBLI": 4657, "PAGE_FIN_PUBLI": 19970326 } }, "META_COMMUN": { "ID": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "URL": "texte/version/JORF/TEXT/00/00/00/19/89/JORFTEXT000000198906.xml", "NATURE": "LOI", "ORIGINE": "JORF", "ANCIEN_ID": "1LX997277" } }, "SIGNATAIRES": { "CONTENU": "Fait à Paris, le 25 mars 1997.
\n

Jacques Chirac

Par le Président de la République :

Le Premier ministre,
Alain Juppé

Le ministre du travail et des affaires sociales,

Jacques Barrot

Le ministre de l'économie et des finances,
Jean Arthuis
" } }, "JORFTEXT000000382663": { "SM": { "CONTENU": "LES SENATEURS ONT SAISI LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL DE LA LOI PRECITEE ISSUE D'UNE PROPOSITION DE LOI.LE PLAN DE LEUR SAISINE EST LE SUIVANT:
I) L'INCONSTITUTIONNALITE DE LA LOI.
II) LES MOYENS RELATIFS A L'ETENDUE DE LA COMPETENCE DU LEGISLATEUR;1 LES MODALITES D'ADHESION DES SALARIES QUI SOUSCRIRONT INDIVIDUELLEMENT A UN PLAN D'EPARGNE RETRAITE NE SONT PAS DEFINIES.2 LE PRINCIPE DE L'EGALITE ENTRE LES HOMMES ET LES FEMMES N'EST PAS AFFIRME ET NE SERA DONC PAS RESPECTE.3 UNE REGLE MINIMALE DE PARTAGE DES DROITS DE REVERSION LORSQUE L'ASSURE DECEDE A EU SUCCESSIVEMENT PLUSIEURS CONJOINTS N'A PAS ETE FIXEE.4 LA NOTION DE GROUPEMENT D'EMPLOYEURS N'EST PAS DEFINIE.5 LES REGLES QUI CONTRIBUENT A LA PROTECTION DES DROITS DES ASSURES SONT INCOMPLETES.
III) L'ATTEINTE AU PRINCIPE DE L'APPLICATION DE L'AVANTAGE PLUS FAVORABLE EN CAS DE CONCOURS ENTRE ACCORDS COLLECTIFS OU ENTRE UNE DECISION UNILATERALE DE L'EMPLOYEUR ET UN ACCORD COLLECTIFS.
IV) LA MECONNAISSANCE DU PRINCIPE CONSTITUTIONNEL DE LA PARTICIPATION DES TRAVAILLEURS A LA DETERMINATION DE LEURS CONDITIONS DE TRAVAIL.
V) LES ENTRAVES AU LIBRE CHOIX DU PLAN D'EPARGNE RETRAITE.
VI) LA MECONNAISSANCE DU PRINCIPE DE LA LIBERTE D'ENTREPRENDRE.
VII) L'ATTEINTE AU PRINCIPE CONSTITUTIONNEL DE LA PARTICIPATION DES ASSURES A LA GESTION DE LEUR PLAN D'EPARGNE RETRAITE.
VIII) LA MECONNAISSANCE DE L'ART. 15 DE LA DECLARATION DES DROITS DE L'HOMME ET DU CITOYEN.
IX) DES AVANTAGES FISCAUX CONTRAIRES AU PRINCIPE DE L'EGALITE DEVANT LES CHARGES PUBLIQUES.
X) LA MISE EN CAUSE DE L'EQUILIBRE FINANCIER DE LA SECURITE SOCIALE.
XI) SUR LA MECONNAISSANCE,PAR L'ART. 30,DU PRINCIPE DE L'EGALITE DEVANT LES CHARGES PUBLIQUES.
XII) LES MULTIPLES ATTEINTES AU PRINCIPE D'EGALITE." }, "META": { "META_SPEC": { "META_TEXTE_VERSION": { "LIENS": { "LIEN": [ { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "#text": "DECISION97-388", "@sens": "cible", "@cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "@nortexte": "CSCL9701972S", "@numtexte": "97-388", "@typelien": "APPLICATION", "@naturetexte": "DECISION", "@datesignatexte": "1997-03-20" } ] }, "TITRE": "Saisine", "MCS_TXT": { "MC": [ "CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL", "SENAT", "SENATEUR", "SAISINE", "PLAN D'EPARGNE RETRAITE", "CONFORMITE A LA CONSTITUTION", "CONSTITUTIONNALITE", "RETRAITE", "FONDS", "PRINCIPE D'EGALITE", "COMPETENCE", "LEGISLATEUR", "PREAMBULE", "DECLARATION DES DROITS DE L'HOMME" ] }, "AUTORITE": "CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL", "TITREFULL": "CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL Saisine du Conseil constitutionnel en date du 25 février 1997 présentée par plus de soixante sénateurs, en application de l'article 61, alinéa 2, de la Constitution, et visée dans la décision no 97-388 DC" }, "META_TEXTE_CHRONICLE": { "CID": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "NOR": "CSCL9701969X", "DATE_PUBLI": "1997-03-26", "DATE_TEXTE": "2999-01-01", "ORIGINE_PUBLI": "JORF n°72 du 26 mars 1997", "PAGE_DEB_PUBLI": 4666, "PAGE_FIN_PUBLI": 19970326 } }, "META_COMMUN": { "ID": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "URL": "texte/version/JORF/TEXT/00/00/00/38/26/JORFTEXT000000382663.xml", "NATURE": "SAISINE", "ORIGINE": "JORF", "ANCIEN_ID": "1UX9970326P1" } } } }, "texte_version_lien": [ { "texte_version_id": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "cible": true, "cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "id": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "typelien": "MODIFIE" }, { "texte_version_id": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "cible": true, "cidtexte": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "id": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "typelien": "APPLICATION" } ], "textelr": { "JORFTEXT000000198906": { "META": { "META_SPEC": { "META_TEXTE_CHRONICLE": { "CID": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "NOR": "ECOX9601788L", "NUM": "97-277", "DATE_PUBLI": "1997-03-26", "DATE_TEXTE": "1997-03-25", "ORIGINE_PUBLI": "JORF n°72 du 26 mars 1997", "PAGE_DEB_PUBLI": 4657, "PAGE_FIN_PUBLI": 19970326 } }, "META_COMMUN": { "ID": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "URL": "texte/struct/JORF/TEXT/00/00/00/19/89/JORFTEXT000000198906.xml", "NATURE": "LOI", "ORIGINE": "JORF", "ANCIEN_ID": "1LX997277" } }, "STRUCT": { "LIEN_ART": [ { "@id": "JORFARTI000001798132", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001798133", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001606273", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002184323", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001026270", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001412388", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001412389", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001994361", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001926193", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002184324", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001994362", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001539246", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389789", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001994363", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001412390", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389790", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001798134", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002184325", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001798135", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001026271", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002184326", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002115002", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001218230", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002184327", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001412391", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001606274", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001539247", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389791", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001221664", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001994364", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389792", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389793", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" } ] }, "VERSIONS": { "VERSION": [ { "LIEN_TXT": { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000198906", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@num": "97-277", "@debut": "2999-01-01" } }, { "@etat": "ABROGE", "LIEN_TXT": { "@id": "LEGITEXT000005623110", "@fin": "2002-01-18", "@num": "97-277", "@debut": "1997-03-26" } } ] } }, "JORFTEXT000000382663": { "META": { "META_SPEC": { "META_TEXTE_CHRONICLE": { "CID": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "NOR": "CSCL9701969X", "DATE_PUBLI": "1997-03-26", "DATE_TEXTE": "2999-01-01", "ORIGINE_PUBLI": "JORF n°72 du 26 mars 1997", "PAGE_DEB_PUBLI": 4666, "PAGE_FIN_PUBLI": 19970326 } }, "META_COMMUN": { "ID": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "URL": "texte/struct/JORF/TEXT/00/00/00/38/26/JORFTEXT000000382663.xml", "NATURE": "SAISINE", "ORIGINE": "JORF", "ANCIEN_ID": "1UX9970326P1" } }, "STRUCT": { "LIEN_ART": [ { "@id": "JORFARTI000001025634", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001222247", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001413300", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001342705", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001994583", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001796932", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389467", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001413301", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389468", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001535675", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001990977", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001025635", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389574", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002309098", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001607093", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001796933", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001025636", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001921716", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001990978", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" } ] }, "VERSIONS": { "VERSION": [ { "LIEN_TXT": { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000382663", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01" } } ] } }, "JORFTEXT000000748893": { "META": { "META_SPEC": { "META_TEXTE_CHRONICLE": { "CID": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "NOR": "CSCL9701972S", "NUM": "97-388", "DATE_PUBLI": "1997-03-26", "DATE_TEXTE": "1997-03-20", "ORIGINE_PUBLI": "JORF n°72 du 26 mars 1997", "PAGE_DEB_PUBLI": 4661, "PAGE_FIN_PUBLI": 19970326 } }, "META_COMMUN": { "ID": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "URL": "texte/struct/JORF/TEXT/00/00/00/74/88/JORFTEXT000000748893.xml", "NATURE": "DECISION", "ORIGINE": "JORF", "ANCIEN_ID": "2DC997388" } }, "STRUCT": { "LIEN_ART": [ { "@id": "JORFARTI000002186696", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000002389153", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" }, { "@id": "JORFARTI000001025920", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@debut": "2999-01-01", "@origine": "JORF" } ] }, "VERSIONS": { "VERSION": [ { "LIEN_TXT": { "@id": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "@fin": "2999-01-01", "@num": "97-388", "@debut": "2999-01-01" } } ] } } }, "follow": [ "STRUCT.LIEN_SECTION_TA.@id", "STRUCTURE_TA.LIEN_SECTION_TA.@id", "TEXTEKALI", "TEXTELR" ], "id": "JORFTEXT000000748893", "liens_entrants": true }